MHS swimmers enter rarified air
Error message
- Notice: Undefined index: taxonomy_term in similarterms_taxonomy_node_get_terms() (line 518 of /home/middleton/www/www/sites/all/modules/similarterms/similarterms.module).
- Notice: Undefined offset: 0 in similarterms_list() (line 221 of /home/middleton/www/www/sites/all/modules/similarterms/similarterms.module).
- Notice: Undefined offset: 1 in similarterms_list() (line 222 of /home/middleton/www/www/sites/all/modules/similarterms/similarterms.module).

WAUKESHA — There were no surprises.
No shocks or stunners.
And that was just fine with Middleton’s girls swimming team.
The Cardinals, who have dominated on the state’s biggest stage since 2023, continued their reign of terror at the WIAA Division 1 state meet held at Waukesha South High School on Nov. 14.
The Cardinals won their fourth straight state championship and did it in runaway fashion. Middleton finished with 390 points and posted a comfortable win over runner-up Hamilton/Menomonee Falls (204).
Appleton North (152), Verona (150.5) and Madison West (145) rounded out the top five.
The Cardinals became just the third school in state history to win at least four straight championships. Arrowhead won five consecutive state titles from 2002-2006, while Madison West won four straight three times (1980-1983), (1989-1992), (1995-1998).
“I think we showed everyone what we can do,” Middleton junior Abigail Frommelt said. “We practice hard every single day, and just seeing it pay off for everyone meant the world. It was really great to see it.
Middleton’s 186-point win was the greatest margin of victory since Arrowhead posted a 223-point victory over the second place Cardinals back in 2005. Middleton’s 390.0 points were also the third-most in state history, trailing only the 2005 Arrowhead team (407) and the 2003 Arrowhead squad (404).
“I'm always so proud of what these girls can do,” said junior Jane Garlock, who won two individual events and was part of two first place relay teams. “We work so hard in practice, so it's really amazing to see what we can do and show what we can do.”
Senior Brynn Sundell, who also won two individual championships and was part of two first place relay teams, agreed with Garlock.
“This team works super hard every day and it shows,” said Sundell, a University of Wisconsin recruit. “It showed today by how well we all swam and I'm so grateful to have all of them here with me.
“Each one of us pushes each other to be our best and the results show that. We've worked super hard this season, and I'm really glad we won.”
The Cardinals won all three relays — which were each worth 40 points — and notched first place finishes in five of eight individual events. Middleton’s divers also captured two of the top four spots.
“Each one of these girls deserved exactly what they got because of what they put into it,” Middleton coach Andrew Cotton said.
Garlock, who recently committed to Indiana University, won four titles for the second consecutive year and now has 10 championships in her first three seasons. Garlock won individual crowns in the 50- and 100-yard freestyle, and was also part of Middleton’s 200- and 400-yard freestyle relay teams that cruised to first place finishes.
“I was really proud with how I did,” Garlock said of her big day. “I’m just proud of the whole team.”
With good reason.
Sundell matched Garlock with four championships of her own, winning the 200- and 500-yard freestyle, and swimming on Middleton’s first place 200-yard medley relay and 400-freestyle relay teams.
“I was super excited with how today went,” Sundell said. “I'm really happy with how I swam.”
So was Frommelt, who notched three first place finishes and one second.
Frommelt joined Garlock on the championship 200- and 400-yard freestyle relay teams. She also ran away with the 200-yard individual medley and was second — just 0.01 seconds out of first — in the 100-yard butterfly.
Amazingly, Frommelt switched individual events this year and was swimming the 200-yard individual medley and the 100-yard butterfly for the first time at state.
“She works so hard and she does everything the right way,” Cotton said of Frommelt. “To come into different events and perform like she did made me really proud of her. With all the hard work she’s put into this, I think it was just extra special to see her succeed like that.”
The Cardinals succeeded from the get-go.
Middleton got an early lift from its divers, as sophomore Quinn Mazur finished second overall and freshman Nora Vavilov was fourth. Together, the duo combined for 32 points which vaulted the Cardinals into the lead before the swimming portion of the day even began.
Middleton was without sophomore diver Hanna Jodlowski — who won the 2025 state championship, but suffered a wrist injury last month — or its lead would have likely been even larger.
“The divers gave us a great lift,” Cotton said. “Really proud of them.”
Middleton then took its act to the pool and put on a 3-hour show.
The Cardinals’ quartet of junior Tae Martin, junior Helen Machleidt, Sundell and senior Rian Jost began the swimming portion of the day by winning the 200-yard medley relay in one of the most exciting events of the meet. Middleton’s foursome finished in 1:42.49, edging runner-up Appleton North (1:42.53).
“I was really happy with the medley relay,” Cotton said. “I feel like that was really hard because it was close, and they did just a tremendous job.”
The sensational Sundell then cruised to a first place finish in the 200-yard freestyle in an eye-popping time of 1:47.91. That was a full second faster than her seed time and nearly four seconds faster than runner-up Ava Jewell of Muskego (1:51.39).
“I was really happy with my 200 freestyle,” Sundell said.
Junior Poppy Sickler added an eighth place finish in the 200-freestyle, and just like that, Middleton had put up 103 points and had a 45-point lead on second place Menomonee Falls/Hamilton (58).
Frommelt then captured a state championship in the 200-yard individual medley, posting a sensational time of 2:01.02, which was more than four seconds faster than runner-up Avery Antoniewski of Waukesha South/Mukwonago (2:05.47). Frommelt also trimmed 1.43 seconds off her seed time on her way to first place.
“I just touched the wall and I was like, yes, finally everything is starting to pay off,” Frommelt said. “It just felt so good and so surreal, like seeing my parents and my sister up there (in the crowd). It meant the world, definitely.”
Middleton’s Machleidt added a fourth place finish in 2:05.72 and Martin was seventh in 2:07.50 as the Cardinals continued to expand their lead.
Garlock followed that with a first place finish in the 50-yard freestyle in 22.80 seconds. That vaulted Middleton’s lead to 170-87 over second place Falls/Hamilton.
“That race I executed really well,” Garlock said. “I think I just really did that race the right way.”
Frommelt narrowly missed out on a second individual state title when she was second in the 100-yard butterfly. Appleton North’s Elise Brazzale won the race in 54.89 seconds, edging Frommelt (54.90) by 0.01 seconds.
Jost added a third place finish in 55.44 seconds.
“It was a great race,” Frommelt said. “I can’t be too disappointed with second.”
Garlock then cruised to a championship in the 100-yard freestyle, winning that race in 49.96 seconds and easily outdistancing runner-up Ava Jewell of Muskego (51.51).
“That’s a new best time for me,” Garlock said of the 100-yard freestyle. “I was really proud of that.”
Sundell then won her second individual crown, rolling to a title in the 500-yard freestyle in 4:53.11. That was 5.61 seconds faster than Nani Arakawa of Madison Memorial.
Middleton’s Olivia Rashid was fifth in 5:09.42.
The Cardinals’ 200-yard freestyle relay team of Frommelt, Jost, junior Addi Haack and Garlock took first in the 200-yard freestyle relay in 1:33.45, beating their time from sectionals by nearly a full second. Verona was a distant second (1:36.23) and Muskego was third (1:36.82).
Martin followed with a fourth place finish in the 100-yard backstroke, finishing in 56.53 seconds, while MHS sophomore Addy Hynes was 10th in 58.15. Antoniewski of Waukesha South/Mukwonago won the race in 55.52 seconds.
Jost added to her terrific state tournament with a second place finish in the 100-yard breaststroke in 1:02.53, just 0.17 seconds behind champion Maddie Loken of Appleton North (1:02.36). Middleton’s Helen Machleidt added a fifth place finish in 1:03.49.
“The great thing about high school swimming is we always put the team first,” Cotton said. “And you know, there's a tradition of excellence here that we want to uphold at Middleton, and each and every year, they know what our goal is, and that's to win state.
“And so, I continue to challenge them to be the best version of themselves, and they in turn challenge themselves, and they get the most out of me, and I try to get the most out of them. And I think that happened today.”
It continued to happen in the final race of the day, as Middleton closed the meet in style.
The Cardinals’ 400-yard freestyle team of Frommelt, Sundell, Garlock and Martin cruised to first place in 3:22.43. That was 9.45 seconds faster than runner-up Hamilton/Falls (3:31.88) and nearly four seconds faster than Middleton’s seed time.
“I love finishing with that race,” Frommelt said. “It's like the crowd is always electric at the end, and we're finishing it off.”
Sundell agreed.
“That's definitely a fun one,” she said of the 400-yard freestyle. “Like, not only is it the last relay of the meet, but definitely it meant more to me today because I was able to go last and it was my last race at Middleton.”
The Cardinals’ dominance at state capped a season in which they went undefeated against a challenging schedule that Cotton designed to push them from start to finish.
“Last year, I thought we swam really well,” Cotton said. “This year, I knew in order for us to take it up a notch, that we needed to do something different and we needed to work even harder. So I looked at ways that we could amplify and improve our team even more.
“If you truly want to take that next step, you gotta do stuff differently. So that's what I tried to do, and they responded really well, and they took every challenge head on, and that's why they're state champs.”
Middleton loses standout seniors Sundell and Jost, but returns a group that will be consensus favorites to win a fifth straight state title. If the happens, the Cardinals will join Arrowhead as the only programs to have ever notched that remarkable feat.
“That’s pretty surreal,” Frommelt said.
The Cardinals will worry about that come next fall, though. For now, they wanted to bask in the glory of another dominant performance capped with a fourth straight championship trophy.
“To go four for four means a lot to me,” Sundell said. “This team is definitely amazing.
“I made some really great memories with this team that I’ll take with me forever. The whole thing is just very rewarding.”
Nov. 15
WIAA Division 1 state swimming meet
Team scores
1, Middleton, 390; 2, Menomonee Falls/Hamilton, 204; 3, Appleton North, 152; 4, Verona Area, 150.5; 5, Madison West, 145; 6, Arrowhead, 143; 7, Madison Memorial, 116; 8, Muskego, 115; 9, Bay Port, 93; 10, Divine Savior Holy Angels, 84; 11, Monona Grove, 74; 12, Germantown, 73; 13, Pewaukee/Oconomowoc, 59; 14, Brookfield East, 57; 15, Oregon, 56; 16, Sun Prairie East, 43; 17, Waukesha South/Mukwonago, 37; 18, Waukesha North/Kettle Moraine, 36; 19, Hartford Union/Slinger, 32; 20, Badger Co-op, 27; 21, Waukesha West/Catholic Memorial, 26.5; 22, Stevens Point Area Senior High, 25; 22, Kenosha Indian Trail, 25; 24, Milwaukee Lutheran Co-op, 21; 25, Appleton East Co-op, 17; 25, Wausau West, 17; 27, DeForest, 14; 27, Neenah, 14; 29, Racine Case Co-op, 12; 29, Fond du Lac, 12; 29, Sun Prairie West, 12; 32, Appleton West/Kimberly, 9; 33, Eau Claire Memorial, 8; 34, Burlington Co-op, 7; 34, Waunakee, 7; 36, Holmen Co-op, 6; 37, De Pere/West De Pere, 4; 38, Sheboygan North Co-op, 1; 38, Green Bay Southwest Co-op, 1.
Middleton finishes:
Diving: 2, Quinn Mazur, 490.35; 4. Nora Vavilov, 404.70.
200-yard medley relay: 1, Middleton (Tae Martin, Helen Machleidt, Brynn Sundell, Rian Jost), 1:42.49.
200-yard freestyle: 1, Brynn Sundell, 1:47.91; 8, Poppy Sickler, 1:53.72.
200-yard IM: 1, Abigail Frommelt, 2:01.02; 4, Helen Machleidt, 2:05.72; 7, Tae Martin, 2:07.50.
50-yard freestyle: 1, Jane Garlock, 22.80.
100-yard butterfly: 2, Abigail Frommelt, 54.90; 3, Rian Jost, 55.44.
100-yard freestyle: 1, Jane Garlock, 48.96.
500-yard freestyle: 1, Brynn Sundell, 4:53.11; 5, Olivia Rashid, 5:09.42.
200-yard freestyle relay: 1, Middleton (Abigail Frommelt, Rian Jost, Addi Haack, Jane Garlock), 1:33.45.
100-yard backstroke: 4, Tae Martin, 56.53; 10, Addy Hynes, 58.15.
100-yard breaststroke: 2, Rian Jost, 1:02.53; 5, Helen Machleidt, 1:03.49.
400-yard freestyle relay: 1, Middleton (Abigail Frommelt, Tae Martin. Jane Garlock, Brynn Sundell), 3:22.43.

